The Impact of Parental Involvement on Youth Soccer Players: Insights from Recent Research

Last updated on December 15, 2024

A 2021 paper titled “The Role of Parental Involvement in Youth Sport Experience: Perceived and Desired Behavior by Male Soccer Players” investigates a crucial yet sometimes tricky aspect of youth sports: the role parents play in their children’s athletic experiences. The study focuses on male soccer players aged 11-14, and examines how the players perceive their parents’ involvement in their sports activities versus what the players actually want from their parents.

Understanding Parental Involvement

Parents are often the first to introduce their children to sports and continue to play a significant role throughout their child’s sports career. Parents provide not only the logistical support—like transportation and access to sports clubs—parents also provide emotional and financial support. The nature of parents’ involvement can vary widely, with some parents being overly involved, others under-involved, and some striking the right balance. The study explores this spectrum and how it impacts the young athletes.

Key Insights

1. Players’ Perception of their Parents’ Involvement
   • The study revealed that the young soccer players perceived their parents as being moderately to highly involved in their sports activities. This involvement included actively participating in club activities, providing directives, and sometimes applying pressure on the child to perform well.
     
   • Despite this involvement, the children reported low levels of perceived praise and understanding from their parents. They often felt that their parents were more focused on their performance rather than their effort or emotional experience.
     
2. What the Players Wanted from Their Parents
   • When asked what they would prefer from their parents, the children expressed a clear desire for more praise and understanding. They wanted their parents to recognize and appreciate their hard work and to show empathy towards their feelings—whether they were happy, frustrated, or disappointed after a game.
     
   • To put it directly, the players wanted less active involvement and directive behavior from their parents. They preferred that their parents take a step back, allowing the players more autonomy in their sports experience.
     
3. How Parental Pressure Impacted the Players
   • The study identified excessive parental pressure as a significant concern. The young athletes reported that too much pressure from their parents led to increased stress, anxiety; as well as a decrease in their enjoyment of the sport.
     
   • The study highlighted that this pressure often stemmed from parents being overly involved in their child’s sports activities, whether by constantly giving advice, critiquing performance, or focusing too much on winning.
     
4. Finding the Right Balance
   • One of the study’s most important findings is the need for balance. While parental involvement is essential, it should not cross into the territory of overwhelming the child. Parents should focus on being supportive without being controlling.
     
   • A balanced approach involves parents being present and encouraging, celebrating their child’s efforts rather than just their successes, and understanding the emotional highs and lows that come with competitive sports.
     
5. Cultural and Social Influences
   • The study also asserted that the level of desired parental involvement might be influenced by cultural and social factors. For instance, the sport of soccer holds a significant cultural importance in Italy, where the study was conducted, which might explain why the players desired less active involvement from their parents, possibly to avoid the added pressure from the sport’s social significance.

Practical Takeaways

For parents of young soccer players—or any young athletes—this study offers valuable lessons:

• Encourage, Don’t Overwhelm: Your child needs your encouragement, not your control. Focus on their effort and growth, not just the outcomes. Celebrate their small victories and offer a listening ear when things don’t go as planned.
  
• Praise and Understand: Children thrive on positive reinforcement. Acknowledge their hard work, show empathy for their struggles, and let them know that their feelings are valid, regardless of whether they win or lose.
  
• Be Present, But Give Space: It’s important to be involved in your child’s sports journey, but know when to step back. Allow them the freedom to navigate their sports experience on their own, making their own decisions and learning from them.
  
• Avoid Excessive Pressure: Remember that too much pressure can lead to burnout or cause your child to lose interest in the sport altogether. Keep the focus on fun, development, and personal growth rather than just performance and winning.
  
• Seek Balance: Strive for a balanced involvement in your child’s sports life. Being supportive without being overbearing will help your child enjoy their sports experience and develop a lifelong love for physical activity.

The Bottom Line

This study sheds light on the delicate balance parents need to maintain in their involvement in their child’s sports activities. It emphasizes that while parental support is crucial, it should be provided in a way that fosters the child’s autonomy, enjoyment, and long-term engagement in the sport. By understanding and respecting their child’s desires for praise, understanding, and a supportive yet non-pressuring environment, parents can play a pivotal role in ensuring a positive and enriching sports experience for their young athletes.

---

The paper referenced in this article is: Bonavolanta, V., et al., The Role of Parental Involvement in Youth Sport Experience: Perceived and Desired Behavior by Male Soccer Players, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health (2021).

The full paper can be found here.